DOI: 10.1055/s-0042-1748463 - volume 44 - Março 2022
Ana Lúcia Ribeiro Valadares, Jaime Kulak, Lúcia Helena Simões da Costa Paiva, Elizabeth Jeha Nasser, Célia Regina da Silva, Eliana Aguiar Petri Nahas, Luiz Francisco Cintra Baccaro, Márcio Alexandre Hipólito Rodrigues, Marco Aurélio Albernaz, Maria Celeste Osório Wender, Maria Célia Mendes, Rita de Cassia de Maio Dardes, Rodolfo Strufaldi, Rogerio Cesar Bocardo, Luciano de Melo Pompei
Genitourinary syndrome is a complex chronic syndrome with multiple changes in genitourinary tissues in response to menopausal loss of estrogen.
Symptoms range from mild to severe and may have effects on genitourinary and sexual function, relationships and quality of life.
Treatments can be non-hormonal with lubricants and moisturizers or with vaginal or systemic estrogen therapy.
A multidisciplinary approach may be needed when there are complex problems, including sexual dysfunction.
The gynecologist is in a unique position to sensitively discuss the symptoms of genitourinary syndrome, advise, educate and treat appropriately, providing long-term follow-up.
The choice of therapy depends on the severity of symptoms, the efficacy and safety of treatments, and individual patient preference.
Non-hormonal therapies with lubricants and moisturizers are effective for most women with mild symptoms of genitourinary syndrome.
Vaginal estrogen therapy is the most effective standard treatment for menopausal genitourinary syndrome symptoms.
In cases of moderate and severe symptoms, vaginal estrogen therapy or systemic hormonal therapy is recommended, with vaginal estrogen therapy being more effective.
In open prospective studies or randomized trials with small samples, both the microablative fractional CO2 laser and the non-ablative Erbium 2940 nm laser have proven effective in the treatment of genitourinary syndrome.
In women after breast cancer with genitourinary syndrome, first-line treatment is the use of lubricants and moisturizers. Prescription of vaginal estrogen therapy should be avoided; if indicated in particular cases, the severity of symptoms and the oncologist's agreement should be considered.
In cases refractory to treatment, other etiologies should be evaluated, such as vulvodynia, pelvic floor dysfunction, or painful bladder syndrome.
Genitourinary syndrome of menopause (GSM), formerly called vulvovaginal atrophy (VVA), is a syndrome defined as a set of signs and symptoms resulting from estrogen deficiency in the female genitourinary tract, including the vagina, lips, urethra, and bladder. This syndrome includes genital symptoms of dryness, burning and irritation, urinary symptoms and conditions of dysuria, nocturia, urgency and recurrent urinary tract infections (UTIs) and sexual symptoms of dyspareunia and lack of lubrication.1 Although it is more frequent in climacteric women, it can also occur in other situations of hypoestrogenism.1
The genitourinary syndrome of menopause affects peri- and postmenopausal women, with a prevalence ranging from 36% to almost 90%. This condition is also present in pre-menopausal years, with a prevalence of 19% in women aged 40-45 years. Unlike other symptoms of menopause that are temporary and tend to decrease over time, if not treated properly, GSM tends to get worse with age and with longer duration of hypoestrogenism.2
In postmenopausal women, 64% reported loss of libido and 58% avoided any sexual intimacy. In Brazil, 44% of women believe that vaginal symptoms compromise their self-esteem. Even those who are not sexually active can experience discomfort resulting from the symptoms.3
Despite being very common symptoms, more than 70% of symptomatic women do not complain or report these symptoms to their physician. Studies also show that healthcare professionals do not always actively inquire about GSM and often do not prescribe any treatment for women.4
These symptoms are directly related to the reduction in circulating estrogen levels after menopause. Estrogen receptors (ERs; both α and β) are present in the vagina, vulva, pelvic floor musculature, endopelvic fascia, urethra, and bladder trigone. As a result of the estrogen deficiency that occurs in the climacteric stage, histological and anatomical changes occur in urogenital tissues. These changes lead to reduced vaginal elasticity, increased vaginal pH, changes in the vaginal flora, decreased lubrication, vulnerability to irritation and physical trauma. With advancing age, these women become increasingly susceptible to suffering from genital and urinary symptoms.1 4 5
Diagnosis is basically clinical and performed through anamnesis and gynecological examination (Chart 1). The most commonly reported symptoms of genital atrophy are vaginal dryness (55%), dyspareunia (44%) and genital irritation (37%), with an impact on sexual function (59%).6 Physicians should actively inquire about these complaints during the anamnesis because, as discussed above, many women may not spontaneously report these symptoms. Vaginal pH measurement with colorimetric tape, Vaginal Health Index and vaginal maturation index can also be performed.
| SYMPTOMS | SIGNS |
| Vaginal drynessIrritation and genital burningDyspareuniaDecreased lubrication in sexual activityVulvovaginal itchingDiscomfort and acute genital painAbnormal vaginal dischargePostcoital bleeding | Pubic hair lossFusion of the labia minora or synechiaeClitoris foreskin synechiaVaginal introitus stenosisVaginal walls with pale mucosa, loss of roughness and elasticity, often friable and with petechiae that bleed easily on specular examination or Pap smearShortened cervixDifficult visualization of the cervical orificeShortened vagina and sometimes with stenosisPale, dry, thinned vaginal epitheliumVaginal discharge: watery or purulent fluidIrregular erythemaVaginal petechiaevaginal pH ≥ 5 |
| URINARY | |
| Urinary urgencyIncreased urinary frequencyNocturiaDysuriaRecurrent urinary tract infections | Eversion or urethral prolapseUrethral meatus prominence |
Source: Portman et al.1
Chart 1.
Genital signs and symptoms on physical examination
Lubricants and moisturizers are the initial first-line therapies recommended to relieve mild to moderate symptoms of GSM. 4
Vaginal lubricants are used on the partner's penis, vaginal opening, and the woman's vulva before and during intercourse, and can improve pain and ease vaginal penetration by decreasing friction during intercourse. Although these can improve vaginal discomfort and sexual pleasure, they do not have the ability to reverse atrophic changes in the vaginal mucosa.7
Ideally, lubricants should have an osmolality of up to 380 mOsm/kg, but in clinical practice most lubricants exceed this value, with up to 1,200 mOsm/kg being acceptable. Hyperosmotic products can cause irritation and toxicity in the epithelial cells of the vaginal mucosa, which is not the case with water-based or silicone-based iso-osmotic products. They may also contain glycerin, glycerol, preservatives such as propylene glycol or parabens and microbicides. Microbicides can affect the lactobacilli population, decreasing the defense and protection against infections, although not all studies confirm this change in the vaginal flora.7 8 Since there is not much research on the safety and adverse effects of lubricants, it is advisable to give preference to iso-osmotic lubricants and those physiologically similar to natural vaginal secretions.4 8
Vaginal moisturizers are long-acting, non-hormonal products that, unlike lubricants, should be used regularly two to three times a week. Such products contain a polymer that adheres to the vaginal wall for three days and binds to water molecules, which are then released into the vaginal tissue. They are bioadhesives that contain acids such as polyacrylic or hyaluronic or polycarbophil. In some moisturizers, lactic acid is also added to make the pH more acidic.4 9 In a recent systematic review, only five clinical trials with hyaluronic acid were identified and included, totaling 335 women. It showed that the efficacy and tolerability profile of hyaluronic acid are similar to those of vaginal estrogen, thereby making it a good non-hormonal alternative for the treatment of vaginal atrophy of postmenopausal women.9
As data about the effectiveness of lubricants and moisturizers from clinical trials are scarce, most guidelines consider topical estrogen to be superior to vaginal moisturizers, being the standard treatment.4 10 11
The administration of vaginal estrogen therapy (ET) favors the reestablishment of vulvovaginal trophism and is currently the best treatment for this condition. Among the options for vaginal use available in Brazil, we have 17-β-estradiol, promestriene and estriol.4 The recommendation for use of any of these formulations is an initial intravaginal application for 14 days in the evening, followed by a maintenance application two to three times a week while symptoms persist.4 Energy, laser, and radio frequency-based therapies are other options.4
Vaginal tablets with 10 mcg of estradiol show efficient and safe results. In a randomized double-blind study, 309 menopausal women were treated with vaginal tablets containing 10 mcg of estradiol. After 12 weeks, there was a significant improvement in the percentage of parabasal and superficial cells and a reduction in vaginal pH, compared to the placebo group. Clinical improvement was evidenced after four weeks, persisting until the end of the study, at 52 weeks.12 Another study evaluated endometrial safety in 336 women over 52 weeks, without finding an increase in endometrial thickness. 13 Additional safety studies evaluating the endometrium through biopsies have been published, without finding an increase in endometrial hyperplasia or carcinoma.14
The use of estradiol vaginal tablets at a dose of 10 mcg offers local action without significant systemic absorption, and its concentration remains low and stable over time. One study showed that estradiol concentrations remained between 2.44-12.08 pg/mL after 52 weeks of evaluation, being comparable to those in postmenopausal women without treatment.15
After evaluating the risks and benefits, the use of estradiol vaginal tablets at a dose of 10 mcg proved to be effective and safe, becoming the first-line treatment of GSM, especially in patients without other climacteric symptoms.4
It is a synthetic estrogen obtained by double esterification of estradiol used vaginally with local effect, which has not had systemic estrogenic effects. Therefore, it may be a first-line option for women who need minimal vaginal absorption.16
A Brazilian systematic review including nine short-term studies (14-40 days in eight of them) and with a relatively small number of patients demonstrated improvement in symptoms (total or reduced intensity).16 Another uncontrolled clinical trial study demonstrated improvement in vaginal atrophy (p<0.01) and an increase in vaginal health score after treatment with promestriene (p<0.01).17
Evaluation of prescriptions for promestriene for nearly 40 years in 34 countries has shown very low vaginal absorption even after 4-6 months of therapeutic doses.18
It is an estrogen derived from the metabolism of estrone and estradiol in the liver, and its affinity with estrogen replacement RE is around 10% to 15% of the estradiol affinity. Even with this difference in activity, estriol has been used safely and effectively for several years in the treatment of GSM. In six studies included in a systematic review comparing vaginal estradiol and high-dose estriol (0.5-1.0 mg/day), these products were found to be equally effective in relieving the subjective and objective symptoms of GSM.19
In women treated with low-dose vaginal estrogen preparations, the addition of progestin is generally not necessary for endometrial protection, although patients who experience postmenopausal bleeding while undergoing treatment should be evaluated as appropriate.
Laser can be considered a therapeutic option that enables women to avoid hormonal interventions in the treatment of GSM. Microablative fractional CO2 laser or non-ablative YAG Erbium vaginal laser (VEL) can be used.20
Treatment with CO2 laser or VEL is an ambulatory procedure generally consisting of a series of three to four applications at four to six-weeks intervals.20 21
Radiofrequency with a non-ablative effect is another treatment with electromagnetic energy that has also been studied for GSM.20
A recent systematic review included 49 studies that evaluated physical methods of treating GSM. Of these, 37 were about the CO2 laser, of which only four were randomized clinical trials. Ten studies on the Erbium laser were included and only one was a randomized clinical trial. Of the two radiofrequency studies, one was a double-blind, randomized, controlled clinical trial, and the other was a prospective open-label trial. This review suggested that laser therapy is effective and safe in postmenopausal women with GSM. There is still little evidence to support the hypothesis that radiofrequency therapy is safe and effective for GSM 22
Regarding vaginal laser therapy in breast cancer survivors, studies suggest improved vaginal health in this group.23
However, it is important to remember that most studies with energy-based equipment were not simulation or placebo controlled and included a small number of women with a short follow-up time.22 23
Other therapies include vaginal testosterone, vaginal dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA), and oral ospemifene. Although these treatments are not marketed in Brazil, they have proven effective in treating the vaginal symptoms of GSM.4
A systematic review showed that vaginal ET, compared with placebo, significantly reduced urinary urgency, frequency or nocturia, and stress and urge urinary incontinence. For recurrent UTIs, some studies show a reduction in the frequency of infections, although with less evidence.24 25
In cases of treatment failure with vaginal ET, after confirming the correct use of medication, evaluate other etiologies such as vulvodynia, pelvic floor dysfunction26 or painful bladder syndrome.4 26
Patients with GSM who do not respond to vaginal treatments or have contraindications to hormone therapy should be referred to a pelvic physiotherapist for evaluation and treatment.26
Dilators may be useful for patients with GSM who present contraindications to estrogen therapy and have not been able to improve with moisturizers and lubricants. They are also useful for patients with introital stenosis or post-radiotherapy vaginal shortening and/or stenosis.4 26
The treatment of a patient with asymptomatic vaginal atrophy is indicated in some clinical contexts:
In the preoperative period of vulvovaginal surgery. Vaginal ET is used for 14 days before the date of surgery in order to optimize the identification of tissue planes and promote scaring of the wound;27
In the presence of pelvic organ prolapse. In patients with pelvic organ prolapse and pessary users, vaginal ET prevents vaginal abrasions caused by its use;26
A third situation is that of patients with significant vaginal atrophy on physical examination, who have never had vaginal intercourse or have been without sexual activity for some time, and are planning to initiate/resume intercourse with vaginal penetration. Treatment must be offered before the patient has vaginal intercourse in order to avoid painful intercourse and facilitate the resumption of sexual life.26
Hypoestrogenism can cause moderate to severe anatomical distortion in the vulva and vagina. This can include adhesion of the labia majora, introital narrowing, vaginal shortening or stenosis. Treatment should only be carried out if the patient wishes or if she is symptomatic.4 26 Differential diagnosis must be made with vulvovaginal dermatosis or malignant alterations.1 4
For patients with labial adhesion who are symptomatic or wish to resume sexual activity with vaginal penetration, first-line therapy is the use of estrogen in the area of agglutination and application of slight pressure with finger.26
In cases of symptomatic introital narrowing and/or vaginal shortening or stenosis, first-line therapy is vaginal ET associated with the use of graduated vaginal dilators. Estrogen cream can be applied to the dilator. In very serious cases and as exception therapy, if there is no improvement with vaginal ET, surgical options should be discussed with the patient and performed by a trained professional.26
For women with a personal history of breast cancer, first-line treatment is performed with vaginal lubricants and moisturizers. Prescription of vaginal ET should be avoided and performed only in specific situations, depending on the type and characteristics of the cancer, with prior information and consent, in a decision taken in conjunction with the woman's oncologist, evaluating the risks and benefits.28 29 30
The diagnosis of GSM is of paramount importance, as it can negatively affect women's lives. Health professionals need to be more proactive and ask questions during the anamnesis about the presence of symptoms and prescribe treatment when indicated. There is a range of therapies available. For milder symptoms, lubricants and moisturizers are first-line treatments and for moderate to severe symptoms, vaginal estrogen therapy is the most effective and evident. Treatment with low-dose vaginal ET should be continued for as long as symptoms persist, with adequate patient follow-up. New technologies with the use of energy-based treatments such as vaginal laser and radiofrequency have proven effective and safe when used by properly trained professionals, although many aspects still need to be clarified.
National Specialized Commission on Climateric of the Brazilian Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics Associations (FEBRASGO)
President:
Luciano de Melo Pompei
Vice-President:
Lúcia Helena Simões da Costa Paiva
Secretary:
Elizabeth Jeha Nasser
Members:
Ana Lúcia Ribeiro Valadares
Célia Regina da Silva
Eliana Aguiar Petri Nahas
Jaime Kulak Junior
Luiz Francisco Cintra Baccaro
Márcio Alexandre Hipólito Rodrigues
Marco Aurélio Albernaz
Maria Celeste Osório Wender
Maria Célia Mendes
Rita de Cassia de Maio Dardis
Rodolfo Strufaldi
Rogerio Cesar Bocardo